Major Junior Vs The Rest Of Junior Hockey And The NCAA

Junior Hockey News – Major Junior vs The Rest of Junior Hockey and the NCAA #top .wrapper .container h1 { color: #004080; }

Tel: 1-702-551-4654 | Mail:

  • Home
  • About TJHN
  • Advertise
  • Contact

The Junior Hockey News


Visa Prepaid Card

Translation var translate_this_src = ‘en’;
Major Junior vs The Rest of Junior Hockey and the NCAA – Part one

Editors Opinion

Working as an Agent and in some instances as a Family Adviser, I have had the opportunity to work with some great people and some great players. From NHL draft picks to completely unknown prospects, each situation has been different and has presented its own unique challenges.

Players throughout the World have choices to make when looking at the opportunity to play Junior Hockey. Sometimes they have a clear path, sometimes that path is less clear, but more often than not it is a decision based on incomplete information. Far too often I get calls from players and parents that do not understand the choices, or have already made a choice they now regret.

Coaches, recruiters, General Managers, and runners for these people are competing for many of the same players. Some of these people are open, honest, trustworthy and do not apply undue pressure to obtain the player they want. Others are not so above board. You find both groups in every league throughout the world.

Recently, a family called and asked some questions concerning a Major Junior team. The questions asked showed a complete lack of understanding concerning how Major Junior is different from Junior Hockey in the United States, and how Major Junior can effect NCAA playing status. Had this been a parent of an 18 yr old, I would have expected a greater knowledge of the differences. But this was a high calibre Bantam players parent, someone very new to the process and investigation of what to do with their child.

Unfortunately, this parent was receiving information that could have placed the child at risk of loosing his NCAA eligibility.

Its no secret that Major Junior is the largest developer of NHL players. Although NCAA and USHL programs are gaining ground every year, Major Junior will remain the avenue of choice for Canadian players for years to come. Why is that the case?

In Canada, Major Junior hockey is tradition, it is held in high regard, and is the pinicle of hockey outside of the NHL. Players throughout the country talk about "getting there" almost as soon as they play their first competitive games. In the US, NCAA hockey is seen as the pinicle, and the bridge to "the show". This different way of seeing things begins and almost always ends with the parents education within the game and the choices they make for their child. It is not much different than a political view of a Republican family vs a Democrat family. When your raised within and exposed to a belief system, you most often become a product of your environment.

Major Junior is great hockey. Its skilled, fast paced, and features some of the top players throughout the world. NCAA hockey is very similar in those regards, and the USHL is closing ground on Major Junior. Tier II and Tier III Junior Leagues are also great for developing players to promote to these higher levels, players who simply need more time to develop. The question then is what choice to make? Which league to aspire too?

When talking to players and parents I try to keep it simple. The number one question every player needs to ask themself is; "What is my long term goal in hockey?".

So often I used to hear; "I want to play in the show.", or "I want to play pro."

More often now I hear; "I want to get my education.", "I want to play at the highest level possible.", "I want to play college hockey and after that I would hope some minor pro team would give me a look.".

The difference between those answers are largely geographical in nature. The vast majority of calls I get from Canada are still geared toward Major Junior hockey, while those from the US almost always go the NCAA route. The exception for US calls are those callers from cities close to Major Junior or Canadian border towns, and conversely those from Canadian players who have seen NCAA hockey due to their location in a similar border town.

Another difference between Major Junior families and NCAA families quite often comes from the players parents, and the choices they made regarding education.

So often we hear TV announcers saying, "he comes from a farm in Manitoba" or "in the summer he worked at the mill" or similiar phrases describing the "blue collar" background of the family and the player.

More often now we also hear these same announcers saying, "he went to **** University where his father also played", or "he went to the USHL before attending ***** University where his mother graduated from." The difference in decision making influences is pretty clear.

Now that I have provided some background on the decision making process influences, lets look at the decision.

Some players want what they want, you cant change their mind either way if they choose Major Junior, NCAA or another path. Thats fine, and that eliminates some discussion.

Some players have no clue about the choices they are making and how they will influence the rest of their lives. Some do not understand the Education payments from Major Junior, and some have no idea of how to go about playing NCAA hockey. Some have already made these choices unknowingly by making innocent choices they did not know could influence their future. Some make choices based upon bad advice from people who are too closely affiliated with one team or league.

All this said, there is no one league or path that is right for everyone. Some players are sure shot NHL players and for them there is no league they could go to that would hurt them. Those are the very select few players in the world.

For most players though, the NHL is and will always remain an untouchable dream. Sure, we may have friends or team mates that make it, but we need to remember that there are less than 750 NHL jobs. That is 750 out of how many millions of you that aspire to play in the NHL? The odds are better that you will win the lottery.

Thats the bad news.

The good news is that there is a place for everyone within the game.

Come back tomorrow for part two.


Get your FREE extended auto warranty quote! Egnyte Instant FTP


  • Contact TJHN editors, or submit an opinion piece to the editors.


  • Contact TJHN writers, or apply to become a TJHN writer.


  • Contact TJHN marketing staff for your custom tailored marketing plan.

Story Submission

  • Submit a story to our staff that is outside of regular news submissions.


Copyright © 2011 – All Rights Reserved – The Junior Hockey News

About The Author